These Cutler’s Frosted Peanut Butter Cookies are a sugar cookie loaded with peanut butter chips and then topped peanut butter AND chocolate frosting. Can a cookie get any better?
Originally posted March 22, 2012, reposting today with updated photos and notes.
Original post . . .
These Cutler’s Frosted Peanut Butter Cookies are amazing and if you’ve never had one, then you’re in for a treat today!
A thick, soft cookie loaded with peanut butter chips and topped with peanut butter frosting and chocolate frosting . . . do I really need to say anything more?
There is a place in Bountiful, Utah called Cutlers Cookies and Sandwiches. The food is fantastic and their cookies are amazing. I hadn’t had a cookie from Cutlers probably since I was in college and until a few months ago, I had forgotten how much I love them.
Back in December, my husband and I were at a dinner party and someone had brought a plate of cookies from Cutler’s. I’m sure I was drooling when I saw the plate of them. Trying to pick which one to eat, was like trying to choose a favorite child. I ended grabbing a peanut butter one because peanut butter and chocolate are life.
One bite and I instantly realized I had forgotten how insanely good their cookies are . . . they are phonomenal!
Fast forward to a couple weeks ago when I stumbled upon Cutler’s blog, where they so kindly share some of their cookie recipes. I was beyond excited and couldn’t wait to make them. They are absolutely divine! The peanut butter frosting is out of this world and I had to practice some serious self-control so I wouldn’t eat the whole bowl before I frosted the cookies.
I promise you, if you are a peanut butter and chocolate fan, you are going to love these cookies. They’re a chocolate and peanut butter lover’s dream come true.
Be sure and read the notes in the recipe section for helpful hints♡.
Recipe Source: Cutler’s Cookies Blog